There Are Many Truths

Christ with Thomas Rowan and Irene LeCompte, Washington Cathedral, DC

[RCL] Acts 2:14a,22-32; Psalm 16; 1 Peter 1:3-9; John 20:19-31

“There are many truths of which the full meaning cannot be realized until personal experience has brought it home”. A quote by John Stuart Mill.

Sitting at a table in the lunchroom at work the other day, a small group of people began talking about the movie Titanic. One person in the group had not yet seen this movie. No matter what glowing descriptive terms were used, the holdout continued to be sceptical. She was told, “You just have to be there!”

Have you ever been in a situation like that? Sometimes it seems that all the hype about popular films and even best selling books just make us hesitant and doubtful about seeing or reading them. Perhaps we fear we’ll be let down when we find the reality to be less interesting than the publicity has led us to believe it will be.

The truth is that some things just don’t lend themselves well to third person accounts. Sometimes we can be persuaded; at other times we must experience a film or a book for ourselves.

There’s a consistent yearning in most people for powerful experiences. Just look at a current TV schedule. Programs like MasterChef, Home and Away, Married at First Sight, and The Project are common. Thousands pack concerts that pound the senses. We pay big bucks to be “moved.” Being “entertained” isn’t enough; we have to be “touched” in some magical way that leaves an impact on our senses.

We want to be carried away by the crowd, lost in the music, shocked by violence or graphic language or behaviour. We crave salsa that makes us sweat, speed that is breathtaking, sex that sweeps us away, humour that makes us laugh until we cry.

Virtual reality technology can be as addictive as any narcotic. It is not hard to see why. For a child left on his or her own for hours at a time, the thrills of a video game hold far more appeal, for instance, than a book. The stimulation, the sensual impact is so much easier to achieve. There’s no third person effect. The player is plunged immediately into graphic, intense action. The impact is even greater when it is shared with others. Only a player can understand another player’s excitement. If one of the group hasn’t got the newest version of the game, it creates an instant barrier.

Sports fans are another example of the need for instant, intense excitement. Can’t you just see a bunch of twenty-something guys sitting around talking, and suddenly Wally Lewis, the sports mega-hero of the broncos is standing there in the same room with them? Pretty intense for them. But now try to imagine them attempting to explain the incident later to an absent buddy. “Man, I’m telling you, he was really here. He sat right here at this table and drank beer with us. It was totally awesome. What do you mean, you don’t believe us? We saw it with our own eyes!”

It’s not too hard to visualize some doubt on the part of a modern day Thomas.

Some things just need to be experienced to be believed. Perhaps it wasn’t that Thomas doubted his friends’ honesty, or doubted the power that Jesus had. Thomas just wasn’t there. John’s Gospel reads, “But Thomas, one of the twelve, was not with them when Jesus came.”

It was a tragedy that Thomas missed out on a life-shaping moment with the tightly-knit band he belonged to. A Community of Character, a book by Stanley Hauerwas, illustrates the power of shared experiences by referring to Richard Adams' Watership Down. The book emphasizes the importance of gaining a sense of worth from participating and contributing to a common sense of adventure rather than seeking power, security, equality, or dignity. 

In Watership Down, the story about a community of rabbits is formed by the shared adventures they experience. Similarly, in the Christian story, the followers of Jesus are drawn together by their experience of being with him. Thomas felt distanced from his community as he had missed out on an incredible experience that others had been a part of.

Now, we don’t know why Thomas wasn’t there. Perhaps he had a very good reason; perhaps it was a day when he just wanted to be alone. But whatever the reason, Thomas was absent from the band of Jesus’ followers. He just wasn’t there.

It is interesting to speculate about how the story might have been different if Thomas had not been with the community when they next gathered. Or the next time, or the time after that. Communities are living entities that respond to change by protecting themselves. When a living thing is wounded, when a piece of the whole is removed, that living thing begins to seal its wound in order to begin the healing process. If the missing part of the whole is recovered and attached back on very quickly, it may be re-incorporated and resume its place and function. The longer it is disconnected from the whole, the less likely it is to survive the re-incorporation.

We, like the gathered followers of the crucified and newly risen Christ, are a community based on shared participation in the greatest of adventures. Week by week, Christ comes and stands among us, although at times our structure effectively closes its doors against outsiders who might join us. Week by week we break bread with him.

We gathered followers share the stories of the ongoing adventure, bind each others’ wounds, lift each others’ hearts. Together. In Psalm 111, we read, “I will give thanks to the LORD with my whole heart, in the company of the upright in the congregation.” In Acts, we read about 120 people who experienced the power of the Holy Spirit together. They shared the story of this encounter with excitement, and brought 3,000 more people into the community who also wanted to share in that excitement.

If we expect others to believe us, to eagerly join us on this adventure, we’ve got to find a way to help them experience the presence of God in our midst. Our worship and our fellowship need to be open in order to experience the full power of God-in-community. Our excitement when we describe the support of this community must be at least equal to the excitement we express after seeing a good movie!

God, in Christ, has created a community that allows us to derive not only our dignity, but our very lives from our sense of having played a part in the adventure of continuing creation and salvation. What an experience!

You just have to be here!

Amen